The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark search twitter facebook feed linkedin instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content

On July 23, 2008, a 33-year-old iron worker was in the basket of an aerial lift when a crawler crane’s boom collapsed onto the basket, crushing the man to death.  An autopsy revealed that he died from blunt chest and abdominal trauma due to being compressed under the heavy equipment.  He left behind a fiancée and baby daughter.

The man’s family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the contractor in charge of coordinating and inspecting the work.  The defendant claimed the lawsuit should not be considered by a jury because the company did not own, operate, or maintain the crane or aerial lift.  The company also said it had no legal duty to inspect the cable that apparently failed, causing the crane to collapse, and that the subcontractor who supplied the machine should be responsible for making sure the crane was in safe working condition.

It has been over five years, but the family may finally obtain justice.  A judge has denied the defendants motion for dismissal.  In her ruling, the judge said “critical questions on which company was responsible for making certain the equipment was safe should be resolved by a jury.”  A jury trial is set for November 12, 2013.

The 7th Amendment to the Constitution guarantees the right of Americans to a trial by jury. However, big business and insurance companies continue their efforts to strip away those rights. These proponents of tort reform undermine the ability of victims to share their story with a jury and allowing the jury to return a verdict.  Lawsuits and significant jury awards for those who violate safety laws are the number one safety enforcement tool in America.  This is a good reminder that we as a society must held accountable for our own negligence.  Lawsuit Financial is happy the judge in this case understands the importance of the right to trial by jury.  We extend our condolences to the family of the deceased iron worker and best wishes for a fair outcome to this litigation.


  1. Gravatar for jc

    So is Lawsuit Financial going to get a juicy piece of the verdict pie, should a favorable verdict result?

  2. Gravatar for jc

    Mark - -A friend of mine is in the individual health market and just lost his insurance. Remember 3 years ago, President Obama said, "If you like your insurance you can keep it, period." Well now my friend is forced to go on the Obamacare exchanges that don't work and it looks like he will be uninsured as of Jan. 1, 2014 and he could get a fine for not having health insurance. Does he have standing to sue President Obama for fraud?

Comments are closed.

Of Interest